Reflection 70B: Hype vs. Reality 🤔

This breaks down the buzz around Reflection 70B, an open-source language model claiming to outperform giants like GPT-4. We’ll dive into the controversy, analyze its real-world capabilities, and see if it truly lives up to the hype.

💥 The Rise of Reflection 70B

Reflection 70B, launched by HyperWrite co-founder Matt Shumer, boasted impressive benchmarks, suggesting it surpassed even GPT-4 in certain areas.

MMLLU Test: Aced it with 89.9% accuracy (compared to GPT-4’s 88.7%). This test evaluates AI across 57 subjects, highlighting Reflection’s broad knowledge base.
HumanEval Test: Achieved a remarkable 91% success rate, outperforming GPT-4 by 1%. This test focuses on code generation, showcasing Reflection’s programming prowess.

Shumer attributed this success to “Reflection Tuning,” a technique allowing the model to reflect on its answers, similar to how humans double-check their thoughts. 🧠

🤨 Controversy Erupts

Artificial Analysis, a tech media outlet, challenged Reflection’s claims after conducting their own tests. Their findings revealed a significant discrepancy:

MMLLU Test (Re-test): Reflection scored only 79%, a whopping 10% lower than initially claimed.
Suspicious Similarities: They also pointed out that Reflection’s code seemed suspiciously similar to LLaMa 3, raising doubts about its originality.

Shumer addressed the inconsistencies, attributing them to download issues on Hugging Face, a platform hosting AI models. However, even after re-tests, Reflection fell short of its initial claims.

🕵️ Deeper Issues Unfold

The controversy deepened as users began accusing Shumer of manipulating statistics.

Limited Parameters: Skepticism arose as Reflection, with only 70 billion parameters, claimed to outperform models like GPT-3.5 (170 billion parameters).
Censorship Concerns: One user observed that Reflection censored the word “Claude,” fueling speculation that it might be a modified version of Anthropic’s Claude 3.5.

🧪 Putting Reflection to the Test

To assess Reflection’s capabilities, we’ll use OpenRouter.ai, a platform providing free access to the model.

Prompt 1: Persuasion Principles

Request: List all persuasion principles from the book “Influence” by Robert Cialdini and provide three examples for each, focusing on online business.

Result: Reflection successfully identified all six principles and generated relevant examples, demonstrating its understanding of the subject and ability to tailor responses to specific contexts.

Prompt 2: Crafting a Cover Letter

Request: Write a cover letter for an AI Researcher position at a leading tech company, highlighting technical skills, projects, and contributions.

Result: Reflection created a compelling cover letter, showcasing relevant skills and experiences. Interestingly, it even self-corrected its initial mention of less common programming languages in AI, demonstrating its capacity for self-reflection and improvement.

Prompt 3: Cryptocurrency’s Impact

Request: Write a blog post about cryptocurrency’s impact on emerging economies, including advantages, disadvantages, and real-world examples.

Result: While Reflection provided a structured response with relevant examples (Venezuela and El Salvador), the content lacked depth and detailed analysis compared to what GPT-4 might offer.

Prompt 4: Code Generation

Request: Create a simple calculator using HTML, CSS, and JavaScript.

Result: Reflection struggled with code generation, producing a non-functional calculator with disorganized elements. This highlights its limitations in complex coding tasks compared to more advanced models.

🤔 Final Verdict

Reflection 70B, while promising, doesn’t yet live up to its bold claims of surpassing GPT-4.

Strengths:

“Reflection Tuning”: This unique approach allows for continuous self-assessment, potentially leading to more accurate and contextually relevant responses.
Open-Source Nature: Being open-source fosters community-driven development and allows for wider accessibility.

Limitations:

Performance Inconsistencies: The discrepancies between claimed and actual performance raise concerns about reliability.
Code Generation Struggles: Its limitations in complex coding tasks become apparent when compared to models like Claude 3.5 or GPT-4.

🚀 The Future of Reflection

Reflection 70B represents an exciting development in the open-source AI landscape. While it may not yet dethrone the giants, its unique approach and potential for improvement make it a model to watch.

Resources: